At a gathering for singles interested in same-sex relationships, friends Lillian Bell, Ella Reeves, and Charlie Sins are feeling disappointed as they haven't made any connections yet. But their luck soon changes when an unsuspecting newcomer, Whitney Wright, stumbles upon their group. Excited by the prospect of some intimacy, the trio starts charming Whitney, who, to their surprise, reveals she is straight and didn't realize the nature of the event. Despite the initial awkwardness, Whitney becomes intrigued by their proposal to explore new experiences by engaging in a passionate sexual encounter with them. Agreeing to the proposition, Whitney leads the group into a thrilling foursome, ensuring a memorable night for all involved.