Pie Day

Ariella still feels like shit about Maddy catching her with Veronica a few weeks back. Since then it's been pure ice between them. Maddy's pissed at her best friend for getting finger-banged by her stepmom, and she's not thrilled with Ariella either. Ariella's been tiptoeing around, terrified Maddy might spill to her dad. She can’t stop thinking about how good Veronica’s fingers felt, but trying to explain that to Maddy is pointless—they've both clammed up completely. Ariella wants her house back to normal. When Maddy aces a math test, she grabs a fat, creamy pie and waits at the door. Maddy walks in, sees the pie, and her face stays hard. She tells Ariella the only thing the pie is good for is smashing it across her face. Ariella swallows her pride and nods. Maddy doesn’t wait—she slams the whole thing right into Ariella. Cream and crust smear across big tits and full lips. Ariella doesn’t even blink. The mess looks filthy on her, and Maddy’s suddenly curious. She grabs Ariella’s finger, sucks the thick white filling off slow and deliberate, tongue working every inch. Ariella returns the favor: she smears pie down Maddy’s tight body, then spreads her legs and licks into that sweet, wet pussy mixed with sugar. Her tongue pushes deep. Maddy’s hips roll. Anger drains out with every moan as she cums hard, once, twice, shaking. Then the high fades and the old resentment slams back in. The pie tasted good, but maybe Ariella should stick to fingering Maddy’s friends instead of trying to fuck her own stepdaughter again. You decide.